Amityville, a neighborhood in Babylon, Long Island, is more than its famous legends—it’s a dream spot for eating out. Whether you crave comforting Italian pastas, inventive gastropub plates, or crave-worthy baked goods, Amityville’s dining scene is packed with treasures. Here’s a local’s guide to the best dishes, places, and culinary experiences in this friendly corner of Babylon.
Main Street Magic: Where Amityville Eats Shine
Main Street (NY-110) anchors Amityville’s food scene, hosting an eclectic lineup of eateries spanning budget eats to destination dining.
- Park Avenue Grill (9 Park Ave)
This bustling staple near Park Avenue and Merrick Road always draws locals for breakfast and lunch. The menu hits all the classics—fluffy pancakes, buttery omelets, juicy burgers. Everything is freshly prepared, with portions hearty enough to fuel your day. Price: $
- Villa D’Aquila (488 Merrick Rd)
In the mood for Italian? Step into Villa D’Aquila, a family-run gem just off Main Street, where red sauce reigns supreme. Their chicken scarpariello and homemade pastas have a fiercely loyal following. The ambience—checkered tablecloths, wood-paneled walls—feels like a warm embrace. This is the spot for Sunday dinners with Nonna’s spirit at the table. Price: $$
- Swell Taco (135 Merrick Rd)
For a SoCal vibe, Swell Taco delivers with surf décor, vibrant flavors, and legendary margaritas. The Baja fish tacos and carne asada burritos never disappoint, whether you’re on the patio for Taco Tuesday or grabbing takeout before hitting the beach. It’s casual, fun, and just a bit addictive. Price: $$
Coffee, Sweets & Midday Retreats
There’s no shortage of satisfying sweets and café stops in Amityville—perfect for meeting friends or treating yourself.
- Brownstones Coffee (55 Merrick Rd)
Known for its bustling energy and creative espresso-based drinks, Brownstones is where locals go for everything from classic lattes to seasonal cold brews. They serve a full brunch menu (try the Nutella-stuffed French toast!) and offer plenty of nooks for working or chatting. Price: $$
- Red’s Kitchen (340 Merrick Rd)
On the more modern end, Red’s Kitchen wows with Greek yogurt parfaits, signature acai bowls, and excellent sandwiches. Their avocado toast is a fan favorite—topped with fresh radish and pickled onions on crusty multi-grain bread. Health-conscious and delicious. Price: $
- Sweet USA (117 Broadway)
Just a block north of Merrick on Broadway, Sweet USA crafts homemade confections, cannoli, and cakes that locals order for every celebration. Don’t skip their signature rainbow cookies and lemon Italian ice in summer. Price: $
Amityville’s Best-Kept Secret Spots
Some of Amityville’s most exciting food finds are off the beaten path—places only locals and adventurous eaters know to look.
- Nino’s Pizza (58 Merrick Rd)
Nino’s may seem like your standard pizzeria, but the thin-crust pies and grandma slices are the subject of town-wide debates about the “best pizza.” It’s quick, affordable, and always fresh out of the oven. Pro move: order a square pie with pepperoni and a side of garlic knots, then grab a picnic table at nearby Peterkin Park. Price: $
- Blum’s Amityville (78 Merrick Rd)
Dating back to the mid-20th century, Blum’s is an old-fashioned ice cream parlor and candy shop that feels like a time capsule. The house-made fudge, sundaes, and seasonal treats (like Easter egg sandwiches) are pure nostalgic fun. The staff often know local kids by name! Price: $
- Pouran’s Persian Bakery (side street off Broadway)
On a quiet side street, Pouran’s is a true local secret. It’s a tiny family bakery offering authentic Persian breads, baklava, and pastries you won’t find anywhere else in the area. If you see fresh barbari bread in the window, nab it fast—it never lasts long. Price: $
Local Food Trucks & Street Eats
Once the weather warms up, Amityville’s food trucks make their rounds, bringing a festival feel to local events and waterfront parks.
- Rolling Smoke BBQ
Catch Rolling Smoke parked at the Amityville Beach lot or along Broadway. They attract crowds for melt-in-your-mouth brisket, spicy sausage sandwiches, and heavenly mac ’n cheese. Their ribs have won local competitions—absolutely worth tracking via Instagram. Price: $$
- Mariscos El Amigo
On summer nights by Amityville Beach, the Mariscos El Amigo truck serves up fresh Mexican street food—think shrimp ceviche, spicy elote, and loaded birria tacos. Flavors are bold, prices are friendly, and the view of the sunset makes it all better. Price: $
Dining Hubs and Flavorful Traditions
Foodies know that the cluster of eateries near the intersection of Merrick Road and Broadway is Amityville’s informal “food district.” Within just a few blocks, you can wander from taco cravings to Greek classics; from artisanal cupcakes to authentic New York pizza.
Amityville also has a tradition of supporting local—many restaurants source produce from nearby Long Island farms, especially in summer. Look for rotating specials made with North Fork tomatoes, sweet corn, and Montauk seafood.
Why Amityville’s Food Scene Stands Out
What makes Amityville shine?
- Incredible diversity for such a compact area—global cuisines and cherished old-school favorites exist side by side.
- Neighborhood pride keeps standards high: long-time owners greet guests by name, and every spot feels both personal and welcoming.
- Affordability—whether you’re splurging for a celebration meal or grabbing quick bites, you’ll never break the bank.
So whether you’re exploring after a stroll on the Amityville waterfront, meeting friends along Main Street, or hunting down a food truck feast, you’ll find flavors as memorable as the village’s storied past.
Hungry? Amityville’s dining scene is waiting—with a seat at the table for you.